War has disrupted water treatment plants, pumping stations, electricity supplies, and distribution networks across Sudan. Millions of people depend on the work of local water authorities, engineers, humanitarian organizations, and volunteers to restore safe water.

Restoring service requires more than repairing a single facility. Electricity, fuel, treatment chemicals, equipment, access, and public health needs all affect the work. Organizations respond according to their responsibilities, resources, and the information available to them.

Each organization documents its activities and observations. Those records serve immediate operational purposes.

Different organizations. Different perspectives.

Independent documentation

A

Independent documentation

Each organization maintains its own records and reporting schedule.

Independent documentationSchematic examples, not historical evidence. The same independently maintained records appear in both views. A2 and C2 identify Al Manara Water Treatment Plant; B2 is a possible match. Associations do not establish causation. External circumstances change independently.INDEPENDENT DOCUMENTATIONEarlierSubsequentLaterOrganization AOwn recordsA1 · Site assessmentA1 · RecordSite assessmentA2 · Repair milestoneA2 · RecordRepair milestoneA3 · Maintenance recordA3 · RecordMaintenancerecordOrganization BOwn recordsB1 · Fuel deliveryB1 · RecordFuel deliveryB2 · Delivery recordB2 · RecordDelivery recordB3 · Route changeB3 · RecordRoute changeB4 · Logistics recordB4 · RecordLogisticsrecordOrganization COwn recordsC1 · Water quality testC1 · RecordWater qualitytestC2 · Operational reportC2 · RecordOperationalreportC3 · Community surveyC3 · RecordCommunitysurveyThe world keeps changing.Using evidence across organizations requirescoordination or retrospective reconciliation.Independent documentationSchematic examples, not historical evidence. The same independently maintained records appear in both views. A2 and C2 identify Al Manara Water Treatment Plant; B2 is a possible match. Associations do not establish causation. External circumstances change independently.Organization AA1 · Site assessmentA1 · RecordSite assessmentA2 · Repair milestoneA2 · RecordRepair milestoneA3 · Maintenance recordA3 · RecordMaintenancerecordOrganization BB1 · Fuel deliveryB1 · RecordFuel deliveryB2 · Delivery recordB2 · RecordDelivery recordB3 · Route changeB3 · RecordRoute changeB4 · Logistics recordB4 · RecordLogisticsrecordOrganization CC1 · Water quality testC1 · RecordWater qualitytestC2 · Operational reportC2 · RecordOperationalreportC3 · Community surveyC3 · RecordCommunitysurveyThe world keeps changing.Using evidence across organizationsrequires coordination orretrospective reconciliation.
Horizontal position denotes reporting time only. Alignment does not establish a relationship between organizations or records.

Connections across records

B

Evidence across organizations

Discover shared assets, activities, and outcomes.

Evidence across organizationsSchematic examples, not historical evidence. The same independently maintained records appear in both views. A2 and C2 identify Al Manara Water Treatment Plant; B2 is a possible match. Associations do not establish causation. External circumstances change independently.Organization AA1 · Site assessmentA1 · RecordSite assessmentA2 · Repair milestoneA2 · RecordRepair milestoneA3 · Maintenance recordA3 · RecordMaintenancerecordOrganization BB1 · Fuel deliveryB1 · RecordFuel deliveryB2 · Delivery recordB2 · RecordDelivery recordB3 · Route changeB3 · RecordRoute changeB4 · Logistics recordB4 · RecordLogisticsrecordSHARED SUBJECTAl ManaraWater Treatment Plantidentifiespossible matchOrganization CC1 · Water quality testC1 · RecordWater qualitytestC2 · Operational reportC2 · RecordOperationalreportC3 · Community surveyC3 · RecordCommunitysurveyidentifiesThe world keeps changing.New evidence becomes discoverable and verifiableas organizations contribute it.Evidence across organizationsSchematic examples, not historical evidence. The same independently maintained records appear in both views. A2 and C2 identify Al Manara Water Treatment Plant; B2 is a possible match. Associations do not establish causation. External circumstances change independently.Organization AA1 · Site assessmentA1 · RecordSite assessmentA2 · Repair milestoneA2 · RecordRepair milestoneA3 · Maintenance recordA3 · RecordMaintenancerecordOrganization BB1 · Fuel deliveryB1 · RecordFuel deliveryB3 · Route changeB3 · RecordRoute changeB2 · Delivery recordB2 · RecordDelivery recordB4 · Logistics recordB4 · RecordLogisticsrecordSHARED SUBJECTAl ManaraWater Treatment Plantidentifiespossible matchOrganization CC1 · Water quality testC1 · RecordWater qualitytestC2 · Operational reportC2 · RecordOperationalreportC3 · Community surveyC3 · RecordCommunitysurveyidentifiesThe world keeps changing.New evidence becomes discoverableand verifiable as organizationscontribute it.
Records remain independently maintained. Identifying the same asset does not establish causation.

Independent documentation

A

Independent documentation

Each organization maintains its own records and reporting schedule.

Independent documentationSchematic examples, not historical evidence. The same independently maintained records appear in both views. A2 and C2 identify Al Manara Water Treatment Plant; B2 is a possible match. Associations do not establish causation. External circumstances change independently.Organization AA1 · Site assessmentA1 · RecordSite assessmentA2 · Repair milestoneA2 · RecordRepair milestoneA3 · Maintenance recordA3 · RecordMaintenancerecordOrganization BB1 · Fuel deliveryB1 · RecordFuel deliveryB2 · Delivery recordB2 · RecordDelivery recordB3 · Route changeB3 · RecordRoute changeB4 · Logistics recordB4 · RecordLogisticsrecordOrganization CC1 · Water quality testC1 · RecordWater qualitytestC2 · Operational reportC2 · RecordOperationalreportC3 · Community surveyC3 · RecordCommunitysurveyThe world keeps changing.Using evidence across organizationsrequires coordination orretrospective reconciliation.
Independent recordEstablished asset identificationPossible match

Schematic examples · not historical evidence

Investigating Al Manara

We began with a broad internet search about water restoration in Sudan. AI helped us identify reports, organizations, and facilities. Establishing which information was reliable required us to find and check the original sources.

Even identifying the same water treatment plant required investigation.

Al Manara. El Mannara.

Different spellings appeared in different reports. We had to establish that they referred to the same facility.

Then we encountered two accounts of its restoration.

January 22, 2025 — Asdaa Sudania

Al Manara was reported to be operating at 25% capacity, with a forecast of 66% after all generators became operational. The report attributed these figures to Muhammad Ali Al-Ajab, Director of the Khartoum Water Authority.2

May 29, 2025 — UNICEF

El Mannara Water Treatment Plant was reported to have reached approximately 50% operational capacity, with one 1,000 kW generator installed and operating.3

The reports described work at the same water treatment plant, months apart. Their authors had different responsibilities and reasons for reporting. Neither report needed to account for the other.

A responder trying to restore service, or a funder deciding where to direct resources, might never encounter both.

We found them through a retrospective investigation. We checked the original sources, established that the different names referred to the same facility, and recorded the source packages and our findings on Geeq.

Imagine discovering those records while the work was still underway.

Suppose the organizations had contributed their records as they worked, making them available for others to discover and verify.

A responder searching for a water treatment plant finds reports from organizations they have never worked with. A funder sees what has been reported about the same facility, by whom, and when.

Neither has to wait for an introduction or ask someone to assemble the records. They can find the original reports, including the Arabic source, and check the evidence themselves, whenever they need it.

Participating organizations could contribute records through their own applications and processes, without having to establish a common reporting system or coordinate with everyone who might eventually use them.

Their records could inform decisions they never knew were being made.

Explore the Al Manara investigation

Explore the original source records, reported findings, and recorded receipts.

Screenshot of the Al Manara investigation application: the “Examine the sources” evidence cards for the Al Manara Water Treatment Plant.

What are you trying to understand?

Some of the most consequential questions involve records held by different people and organizations.

Bring us a problem. Let's explore what we can build together.

Contact Settlement Infrastructure →

Sources

  1. 1.
  2. 2.
  3. 3.
  4. 4.
  5. 5.
  6. 6.
  7. 7.